# Luce SG vs EduNanny by Butler: prices and reviews compared

**As of 6 November 2026, Luce SG has a Google rating of 4.9 from 8609 reviews and its lowest published price is Babysitter from S$21.80/hr; EduNanny by Butler has 4.8 from 63 reviews and Nanny from S$25/hr. Luce SG has the higher rating. Both are listed under Nanny / Babysitter in Singapore on KakiList.**

## In short

- [Luce SG](https://kakilist.com/provider/luce-sg-4881): 4.9 from 8609 Google reviews; lowest published price **Babysitter from S$21.80/hr**.
- [EduNanny by Butler](https://kakilist.com/provider/edunanny-by-butler-10176): 4.8 from 63 Google reviews; lowest published price **Nanny from S$25/hr**.
- Prices checked 6 November 2026 from each provider's own website or another public page; every price links to its source.
- Each lowest price is for that provider's cheapest published item, which may not be the same thing at both: compare the price lists below.

Source: KakiList, https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/luce-sg-10154-vs-edunanny-by-butler-10176. This page as plain text: https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/luce-sg-10154-vs-edunanny-by-butler-10176/md.

## Side by side

|  | [Luce SG](https://kakilist.com/provider/luce-sg-4881) | [EduNanny by Butler](https://kakilist.com/provider/edunanny-by-butler-10176) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Google rating | 4.9 | 4.8 |
| Google reviews | 8609 | 63 |
| Lowest published price | Babysitter from S$21.80/hr | Nanny from S$25/hr |
| Published prices listed | 4 | 1 |
| What reviewers say | Luce SG shows inconsistent performance across cleaning and handyman services. | EduNanny caregivers maintain consistent communication with parents through daily updates during drop-off and pick-up, and provide real-time monitoring via their web-based app and nap camera features. |
| Address | 100D Pasir Panjang Rd, #05-02, Singapore 118520 | 808 French Rd, #07-177, Singapore 200808 |

## Published prices of Luce SG

| For | Price | Kind of price | Checked | Source |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Recurring Babysitting, minimum 4 hours | S$21.80 | per hour | 6 Nov 2026 | [Website](https://www.luce.sg/services/babysitter) |
| Recurring Babysitting, minimum 3 hours | S$23.98 | per hour | 6 Nov 2026 | [Website](https://www.luce.sg/services/babysitter) |
| One Time Babysitting, minimum 6+ hours | S$25.07 | per hour | 6 Nov 2026 | [Website](https://www.luce.sg/services/babysitter) |
| One Time Babysitting, minimum 2 hours | S$27.25 | per hour | 6 Nov 2026 | [Website](https://www.luce.sg/services/babysitter) |

## Published prices of EduNanny by Butler

| For | Price | Kind of price | Checked | Source |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Private Nanny Services, rates start from | S$25 | per hour | 6 Nov 2026 | [Website](https://edunanny.com/) |

## Frequently asked questions

### Which is cheaper, Luce SG or EduNanny by Butler?

Their lowest published prices are not for the same thing, so compare the price lists: Luce SG publishes Babysitter from S$21.80/hr and EduNanny by Butler publishes Nanny from S$25/hr (checked 6 November 2026). These are each one's lowest published price; what it includes can differ, so compare the full price lists on this page and ask both for a written quote.

### Which has better reviews, Luce SG or EduNanny by Butler?

Luce SG has a Google rating of 4.9 from 8609 Google reviews; EduNanny by Butler has 4.8 from 63 Google reviews. A rating from more reviews is the steadier one. Read the recent reviews on each provider's page before you decide.

### Where do these figures come from?

Ratings and review counts are from Google. Prices are from each provider's own website, or another public page that quotes its prices, checked on 6 November 2026; each price links to its source. Both can change at any time.

[Babysitter & nanny rates compared](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/babysitter-rates-compared) [The cheapest babysitter or nanny service in Singapore](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/cheapest-babysitter-singapore)

Compare two providers

[Luce SG vs Meide Babysitting Services](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/luce-sg-10154-vs-meide-babysitting-services-10168) [Luce SG vs DomesticOne](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/luce-sg-10154-vs-domesticone-10165) [Luce SG vs Aunty SG](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/luce-sg-10154-vs-aunty-sg-10160) [Luce SG vs NannyPro](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/luce-sg-10154-vs-nannypro-10162) [Meide Babysitting Services vs DomesticOne](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/meide-babysitting-services-10168-vs-domesticone-10165) [Meide Babysitting Services vs Aunty SG](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/meide-babysitting-services-10168-vs-aunty-sg-10160) [Meide Babysitting Services vs NannyPro](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/meide-babysitting-services-10168-vs-nannypro-10162) [Meide Babysitting Services vs EduNanny by Butler](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/meide-babysitting-services-10168-vs-edunanny-by-butler-10176) [DomesticOne vs Aunty SG](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/domesticone-10165-vs-aunty-sg-10160) [DomesticOne vs NannyPro](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/domesticone-10165-vs-nannypro-10162) [DomesticOne vs EduNanny by Butler](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/domesticone-10165-vs-edunanny-by-butler-10176) [Aunty SG vs NannyPro](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/aunty-sg-10160-vs-nannypro-10162) [Aunty SG vs EduNanny by Butler](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/aunty-sg-10160-vs-edunanny-by-butler-10176) [NannyPro vs EduNanny by Butler](https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/nannypro-10162-vs-edunanny-by-butler-10176)

---

Web page: https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/luce-sg-10154-vs-edunanny-by-butler-10176
CSV of the table: https://kakilist.com/guides/childcare/compare/luce-sg-10154-vs-edunanny-by-butler-10176/prices.csv
Every price comparison on KakiList, and the prices address for assistants: https://kakilist.com/llms.txt

KakiList (kakilist.com) is a Singapore directory of home and family service providers that shows each provider's Google rating and review count, its ACRA business registration where verified, and the prices it publishes, with price comparisons in Singapore dollars that give the date checked and the source of every price.
